Skip to main content

Church Withholding of FICA Taxes

Question:

Businesses withhold and match 7.65% of employees' pay for their social security and Medicare taxes. Can a church pay an employee’s 7.65% or not?

Answer:

We must segregate ministerial and non-ministerial employees in this consideration. Churches must withhold and match FICA for non-ministerial employees unless they have filed Form 8274-Certification by Churches ... Electing Exemption From Employer Social Security and Medicare Taxes. Then the church employee is responsible to pay the full 15.3% himself or herself on Schedule SE, Section B, line 5a.

Churches may not withhold and match FICA for ministerial employees. I encourage churches to help their pastors with these costs but they cannot treat them as non-ministerial. It can actually hurt the pastor’s tax situation. Let me illustrate.

1. If a church wishes to “help” – a) calculate a 7.65% bonus to add to his pay by multiplying his cash compensation + housing allowance X 7.65%, b) then withhold an identical amount as federal income tax withholding. When he files his return and calculates his 15.3% self-employment tax (entered on Form 1040, line 56 from Schedule SE), he will have an extra large amount entered on line 61 as federal income tax withholding to offset his total SE + income tax. Of course, the “bonus” is also taxable income.

2. How can a church’s erroneous classification of its pastor as a non-ministerial employee “hurt”? – when a pastor calculates his 15.3% SE tax on Schedule SE, he can reduce the self-employment income amount by employee business expenses and 403(b) retirement contributions. This reduces his SE tax rather than having it withheld as FICA tax before these items are subtracted.

3. Further, by classifying a minister as a non-minister he becomes ineligible for a housing allowance and SE tax-reducing 403(b) contributions.

Numerous entries in this blog document these statements and examples.

Comments

  1. Regarding ministers and Schedule SE: Can ministers reduce SE income for 403b contribution the minister makes?
    Where is that stated by the IRS?

    I thought ministers 403b contribu- tions were still taxable for Social Security taxes.

    Or is it just the employer's contributions that are not taxable?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Perhaps the easiest way for me to respond to the March 29 comment is to ask readers to type the search term "403" in the above window. I believe it will offer a good review and citations for authority that may be helpful.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Qualified Small Employer HRAs

On December 13, 2016, President Obama signed the 21st Century Cures Act, allowing qualified small employers to offer Health Reimbursement Arrangements (HRA) that follow certain terms.

After the Affordable Care Act was passed, the IRS originally determined that an HRA was not a qualified group health plan. The Cures Act overrules this decision. HRAs are again an option for qualifying small employers.

To be eligible, the small employer must have fewer than 50 employees and must not offer a group health plan to any of its employees.

The Qualified Small Employer Health Reimbursement Arrangement (QSEHRA) must be subject to the following terms.
No salary reduction contributions may be made (i.e., 100% employer-funded).Employer must receive proof of employee’s minimum essential coverage.Reimbursements must be for qualifying medical expenses.Reimbursements for any year cannot exceed $4,950 (or $10,000 for family coverage), which will be adjusted annually for inflation.Employer must offer the …

Gifts Paid Out of Church Funds: Form 1099-MISC Requirements

Question:
 A church gave a wedding gift of $1000 to a couple who are church members. No goods or services were provided by the couple in exchange for the gift.  Is a Form 1099-MISC required? 
Answer: In the following answer, we assume that the couple are not employees of the church from whom the gift could not be viewed as compensation for their services. Also, the amount seems to be small enough to avoid any concerns of "private inurement."

Accordingly, no Form 1099-MISC is required. According to the 2017 IRS Instructions for Form 1099-MISC a Form 1099-MISC is only required for payment of goods or services. The requirements are as follows:
"File Form 1099-MISC, Miscellaneous Income, for each person to whom you have paid during the year:  At least $10 in royalties (see the instructions for box 2) or broker payments in lieu of dividends or tax-exempt interest (see the instructions for box 8);  At least $600 in:  1. Rents (box 1);  2. Services performed by someone who is not your …

Revised Form I-9 Released

The U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services released a revised Form I-9. All new hires after January 21, 2017, must complete the revised Form I-9. All prior released versions of Form I-9 will be invalid for new hires.

Employers are required to have a completed hard copy of Form I-9 on file for each employee. Current employees do not need to re-complete the revised form.

More information on Form I-9 can be found on the USCIS website.