Skip to main content

Minister, is an IRA the Best Option for You? Retirement Alternatives


If I can make retirement contributions to both a Traditional IRA and to a church plan is there a reason to prefer one over the other?


Yes! Most ministers should likely be choosing a 403(b) church plan.

In addition to a Traditional IRA, a minister may choose to claim a contribution to another retirement plan, like a 403(b) church plan. However, before choosing to do so, it is important to understand the benefits and disadvantages of both a Traditional IRA and a 403(b) plan.

Contributions to a Traditional Individual Retirement Account are not employer plans that are deducted up front from a minister's pay (reported on Form W-2). Instead, these amounts are truly deducted on his personal tax return. The benefit of the IRA is that it can be funded after December 31st and still count against one's taxable income. Additionally, an IRA does not require church sponsorship and has lower fees to establish an account.

While there are several benefits of an IRA, there are also some disadvantages. First, the annual contribution is limited to $6,000 per year (2019 level). Second, a required minimum distribution (RMD) is mandatory at the age of 70½ even if the pastor continues to serve full-time as an employee. Third, IRAs only reduce income tax, but do not reduce self-employment (SECA) tax.

Contributions to a 403(b) plan are made as “elective deferrals” from the minister's church compensation, then transmitted to a 403(b) investment account. The amount the minister elects to have withheld from his pay reduces his taxable employee compensation. Ministers over the age of 49 can contribute as much as $25,000 per year (2019 level). Internal Revenue Code 403(b) plans can also be established with employer matching benefits if the church is willing and able to afford the typically higher fees to establish such church plans. The amount withheld is not deducted again on his personal return since it was already subtracted from his income by his employer before preparing Form W-2.

For a minister as an employee who is subject to SECA tax, the elective deferrals reduce both income tax and SECA tax. However, unlike a Traditional IRA, a 403(b) plan can only be funded during the calendar year because it is a deduction from his paycheck. It is important to note an exception may exist for certain ministers (i.e. traveling evangelists) participating in a "solo 403(b)" which is beyond the scope of this post.

Unlike Traditional IRAs, post-retirement distributions from church-established 403(b) plans may be designated by the church as housing allowance (IRS Audit Technique Guides - Ministers). Also, unlike IRA accounts, ministers who postpone retirement and remain full-time employees by the church after age 70½ can delay receiving RMDs.

If you would like to discuss 403(b) church plan accounts, benefits, or contributions further, please contact us at


Popular posts from this blog

Housing Allowance and Form 1099-MISC Reporting


A church provides its minister a housing allowance, but for other purposes it believes that it must report the full amount of compensation (including the non-taxable housing allowance portion) on Form 1099-MISC (in order to demonstrate the full earnings of the minister). If the church reports his compensation,including the housing allowance, on Form 1099-MISC as taxable income, will he be able to deduct his housing expenses somewhere else on the Form 1040?


This questions brings up a couple of issues. First, most ministers are properly classified as employees who receive Form W-2, not as independent contractors who receive Form 1099-MISC. On Form W-2, Box 1 for taxable compensation is reduced reflecting the church's designation of a portion of his pay as non-taxable. Then in Box 14, it typically reports as a memorandum item his additional non-taxable, housing allowance compensation. In the situation addressed in the question, this Form W-2 reporting may or may not a…

Threat to Tax-Exempt Status? Using Facilities for Profit


Can a church member conduct piano lessons in her church's auditorium without threatening the loss of the congregation's tax-exempt status?


Our answer comes from Matthew Davis, J.D., former attorney with the nationally recognized Christian Law Association, who currently practices law in Wisconsin, Illinois, and Florida.

"As a tax-exempt entity, churches must be careful not only in what activities they engage in directly, but also in how they allow the facilities to be used.

"The primary way in which this can come up relates to the requirement for tax-exempt status that the ministry's activities must relate to its exempt purpose. Assuming the church's exempt purposes are 'religious, charitable, and educational,' (three of the purposes specifically mentioned in the Internal Revenue Code 501(c)(3)), piano lessons would certainly fit within that expectation as 'educational' and therefore not be a problem on the tax-exempt purpose i…

Debits and Credits for Designated Gifts


A church is setting up Quickbooks for its accounting, but its personnel have little experience with fund accounting. What are the entries for the receipt and disbursement of designated gifts and the opening balances?


I recommend that most churches that do not need to present financial statements in accordance with Generally Accepted Accounting Principles observe the following steps. Even those churches that do report using GAAP can employ these methods, but must make some adjustments when preparing their financial statements.

What I will demonstrate relates to what most churches call "designated gifts" (CPAs call these Temporarily Restricted gifts). These are gifts that donors contribute with the intention that the church will spend the funds as they direct. Most churches do not receive "endowment gifts" in which donors prohibit the expenditure of the core gift (CPAs call these Permanently Restricted gifts). Only earnings on the subsequent investments…